Southside Sub Shop

Discover Southside Sub Shop in Elmira, NY for delicious take-out sandwiches, cheesesteaks, fried pickles, hot pepper relish, and more. Enjoy fresh rolls, mac salad, chicken strips, and sweet brownies—perfect for a quick, satisfying meal!

MenuContact

Welcome to Southside Sub Shop

Signature Dining Experience

Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop

Located at 374 S Main St, Elmira, NY, Southside Sub Shop serves up mouthwatering subs that keep the locals coming back for more. This sandwich shop is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious, high-quality subs wrapped with care. The aroma of fresh rolls fills the air as you step inside, leading to an enticing menu brimming with options for every palate. Whether you're a fan of hearty hot subs or refreshing cold subs, the selection guarantees satisfaction.

The community loves this spot for its famous cheese steak sub, crispy fried pickles, and unique hot pepper relish. It's a take-out only establishment that prioritizes convenience, allowing you to grab your meal and enjoy it wherever you please.

Location & Contact

Address

374 S Main St, Elmira, NY 14904, United States

Phone

+1 607-734-7045

About

Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop
Southside Sub Shop

Southside Sub Shop prides itself on its commitment to quality and community. Established to provide Elmira with hearty and flavorful sandwiches, it has become a local staple. The shop's success comes from using fresh ingredients and maintaining a welcoming vibe. Locals rave about the cheese steak sub; its juicy beef and melty cheese combo wrapped in a warm roll is a favorite among frequent visitors.

The fried pickles add a nice crunch, complementing your meal perfectly. For those looking to satisfy a sweet tooth, the brownie is a delightful addition to any order. As a take-out only shop, Southside makes it easy for customers to enjoy their food on the go. Visitors planning to come by should consider peak hours, especially Fridays at 6 PM, when the shop reaches 100% capacity. Pro tip for newcomers: Beat the rush by visiting during quieter times, typically earlier in the day or late evening, ensuring a quicker and more enjoyable experience.

Work Hours

  • Sunday10 AM-9 PM
  • Monday10 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-10 PM
  • Friday10 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-10 PM

Southside Sub Shop stands out with its diverse menu featuring 29 options, all centered around the beloved sandwich. Popular categories include deep-fried appetizers like crispy cheese fries and flavorful onion rings, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. The menu also highlights a delicious array of hot subs such as the irresistible meatball and the comforting sausage with peppers. For lighter choices, cold subs and tossed salads make their appearance, ensuring everyone finds something to enjoy. The prices are incredibly friendly, averaging just over $4 per item, allowing for a satisfying meal without breaking the bank. With peak times mostly centered around dinner hours, particularly on Fridays, expect a vibrant atmosphere full of eager patrons.

Southside Sub Shop

The exterior of Southside Sub Shop features a bright and inviting facade that draws you in from S Main St. Its casual vibe communicates that this is a place for good food and friendly service without pretense. Seating is not available since the focus remains on take-out, which adds to the bustling energy during peak times. Food lovers often line up on Fridays, sharing their excitement about their favorite subs. Elmira’s warmth reflects in the shop, fostering a sense of community where regulars greet each other and exchange food recommendations while waiting for their orders to be prepared.

Customer Reviews

Delicious subs! A great place to order ahead or walk in. Portions are huge. Excellent prices too. The employees were helpful and very kind. I can't wait to go back and try more. No place to sit and eat, this is a take out place only.

H
Holly W.

This sub shop has great subs, great service and great potential. Had they the means to toast their subs like the meatball and steak and cheese, they could take it to the next level. As it stands, the people working here are courteous, helpful and dedicated, the food is good, the prices very reasonable, and the service is very good. I've become a patron. I wish they had an oven to bake or toast their hot subs to perfection.

R
Russ M.

This is a dependable sub shop!! Consistently made subs. Love their rolls and generous with topings! Quick service. Great for dinner option after a busy day, or take up to Harris Hill or Sullivan's monument as a picnic while enjoying our valley's vistas.

C
Cherie W.

Fantastic subs! Best around! awesome selection and staff is friendly! They are quick!

C
Cassandra

Great subs!! Good quality at a good price. Made to order.. a 1/2 size was overflowing; needed a fork! Employees very pleasant through the lunch crowd. Definitely recommend! Just left but cant wait to come back.

R
RE L.

Take out only. Cold Subs are great. Everything was very fresh. Very good rolls. Asked for oil & vinegar instead of mayo. They put both which made it soggy but it was still good.

C
Charlotte M.